Showing posts with label Beaver Dam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beaver Dam. Show all posts

Monday, April 27, 2026

Wisconsin data center tax break to cost state more than $2 billion

From JSOnline:

Tom Kertscher
Wisconsin Watch

This story was produced and originally published by Wisconsin Watch, a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. It was made possible by donors like you.

Wisconsin is poised to forgo more than $2 billion in sales tax revenue to subsidize hyperscale data centers built by trillion-dollar companies such as Microsoft and Meta.

Data centers were granted a sales tax exemption in the 2023-25 state budget, which was approved by the Republican-controlled Legislature and Democratic Gov. Tony Evers as a way to attract economic development to the state.

That means the $1 billion data center in Beaver Dam, a $20 billion complex in Mount Pleasant and a $15 billion facility in Port Washington don’t have to pay the 5% state sales tax, or local sales taxes, on purchases for constructing and equipping their facilities.

When the budget passed in July 2023, the scale of the data center boom was so uncertain that the nonpartisan Legislative Fiscal Bureau did not estimate how much state revenue would be “forgone” under the exemption, aside from a hypothetical example.

But now a fiscal bureau projection is in:

The state will be out $1.5 billion in forgone state sales tax revenue during construction, which can take years, plus $369 million annually once the facilities are built.

The estimates apply to the hyperscale data centers under construction in Beaver Dam and Port Washington and the facilities under construction or planned in Mount Pleasant. A much smaller Epic project in Verona is also part of the estimate.

It’s unclear whether the data centers would have been built in Wisconsin without the tax incentive.

“Obviously it's a big number, but it’s right to think that this is not really revenue that the state realistically could have ever captured,” said economist Ross Milton, a state government tax expert at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

“It seems quite likely that if Wisconsin wasn't providing incentives of these kinds, we wouldn't be seeing these data centers being built here.”

Highlighting the fierce competition for development, 38 states offer data center sales tax exemptions or other tax breaks, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.

Wisconsin offers sales tax exemptions for a wide array of products and services. One of the largest exempts food bought at the grocery store, which reduced state revenue by about $920 million in 2024.

Tricia Braun, executive director of the Wisconsin Data Center Coalition, a business group that supports data center development, pointed out that the fiscal bureau projection does not include economic benefits from data centers, including taxes paid by data center suppliers.

Wisconsin Watch reported in March that just three Wisconsin companies have done more than $1 billion in business supplying data centers.

Jason Stein, president of the Wisconsin Policy Forum, a nonpartisan think tank, said “the state has good possibilities for recovering” the forgone revenue. That could come from spending by construction workers and income taxes paid by those workers, their employers and permanent data center employees, as well as corporate income taxes and utility taxes, he said.

The unexpectedly large amount of forgone revenue has helped fuel efforts for data center regulation.

State Sen. Jodi Habush Sinykin, D-Whitefish Bay, who requested the estimate, said lawmakers should discuss what the state can get in return for the exemption. She said the exemption could be tied to, for example, requirements to protect the environment.

Habush Sinykin wants the Legislature, which Republicans control, to convene what is known as an extraordinary session to discuss a variety of data center bills, rather than waiting until the next regular session in January.

Sen. Romaine Quinn, R-Birchwood, and Rep. Shannon Zimmerman, R-River Falls, introduced legislation in 2023 that led to the exemption and have proposed expanding it. They did not respond to requests for comment.

Their original legislation received more than 200 hours of lobbying support from Microsoft, power companies such as We Energies and Alliant Energy, and business groups. No one registered to lobby against the bill.

Nationally, state data center legislation has shifted from incentives to regulation.

In 2021 and 2022, 44 of the 45 data center bills introduced in states across the U.S. offered tax and economic incentives, according to an analysis released April 22. Since then, many other types of legislation have emerged. In 2026, only 61 of the 262 state data center bills covered incentives. The vast majority dealt with regulation of energy, environment and transparency.

Some states, including Minnesota, have taken steps to restrict or roll back data center sales tax exemptions.

Data center opponent Shawn Haney, a former elected town board member in Dane County, said he understands that Wisconsin created its sales tax exemption to attract economic development. But he thinks it should be modified so that the state can collect some sales tax revenue from data centers.

“I don't think anybody could have forecasted the size and magnitude of these massive data centers,” Haney said.

“You could do some good things with” the revenue, he said, tossing out a few ideas. “Look at all the roads we have to repair.”

From: https://www.jsonline.com/story/money/business/2026/04/27/wisconsin-data-center-tax-break-to-cost-state-more-than-2-billion/89780055007/

Friday, April 10, 2026

We Energies proposes plan to shield ratepayers from data center power line costs

From JSOnline:

Francesca Pica
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

As artificial intelligence data centers are being built in eastern Wisconsin, so too is a massive network of new power lines to serve them.

The American Transmission Company is seeking more than $2 billion in transmission projects that will help serve Microsoft's massive Mount Pleasant campus, Vantage's project in Port Washington and a data center in Beaver Dam built by Meta, parent company of Facebook and Instagram.

Microsoft, Meta and other tech giants have publicly pledged to pay for new power lines supplying their electricity-hungry data centers. But due to the way ATC’s billing works, ratepayers in eastern Wisconsin could face higher costs for transmission lines in the years before campuses go online.

In public filings submitted to state regulators April 1, We Energies says it plans to ensure transmission costs are transferred directly to data center companies in their service territory. The move is intended to shield other ratepayers from hundreds of millions of dollars in extra transmission costs associated with data centers while those projects ramp up.

The utility said it’s working with ATC to submit a plan to federal regulators by the end of April.

The proposal would protect not only We Energies customers but ratepayers across ATC’s footprint, said Bert Garvin, WEC Energy Group senior vice president of external affairs. That includes Alliant Energy and Wisconsin Public Service Corporation territory in eastern Wisconsin, as well as customers in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.

“That was important to us and to the data centers,” Garvin told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. “No other utilities’ customers will be paying for this lag issue as they ramp up.”

In Wisconsin, transmission is one of the “loopholes that would need to be fixed if the world was going to live up to the promises" made by data center companies, said Tom Content, executive director of the state Citizens Utility Board.

Content said he was glad to see We Energies address transmission cost concerns, but is waiting to see specifics of the proposal filed to regulators.

"We have all these promises that the tech companies are going to pay their own way," he said. "We don't have anything in writing today in this case that protects customers from $2.3 billion in costs."

ATC seeking more than $2 billion in new transmission

The state Public Service Commission already signed off on two transmission projects related to data centers.

Part of a $625 million project that was approved in May 2025 includes the construction of a power line to serve Microsoft’s data center campus in Mount Pleasant, built on the former Foxconn site.

In public filings, ATC said the project’s massive energy demand – around 900 megawatts for the first two phases – will overload existing infrastructure.

ATC is also building two new power lines and a substation in Milwaukee and Waukesha counties. The project will cost $423 million and help maintain system reliability as large data centers come online.

Another transmission project, approved in November 2025, will cost $191 million. It will serve Meta’s Beaver Dam data center.

ATC is awaiting approval of a massive proposal to hook up the Port Washington data center campus. It would cost an estimated $1.4 billion to $1.6 billion. ATC also wants to build a $56 million power line in Milwaukee and Racine counties, in part to support the Mount Pleasant campus.

Lag, lower-than-expected energy use could expose residents to higher costs

ATC bills though utility companies, who pass costs onto their customers in rates.

Transmission accounts for around 15% of a We Energies customer's monthly electric bill, Content said. And unlike utilities – which must wait for a power plant to begin service before putting costs into rates – ATC can start charging as soon as shovels break ground on a new power line or substation.

As part of its data center rate proposal, We Energies wants to charge data center companies a transmission service charge once they go online. It would be based on how much energy they use, regardless of whether they meet their projected load.

But that means We Energies would recover fewer costs if data centers used less than expected, Public Service Commission analysts said.

"Put another way, when [data center customers] are charged less through the Transmission Service Charge due to changes in actual demand and energy usage, ATC's other customers will be charged more to make up the remaining transmission costs," analyst William Koebel said in January.

Koebel also said other customers may subsidize data center-related transmission costs in the gap between project approval and when the data center enters service. That gap could last around three to five years.

We Energies plan shields ATC ratepayers from $561 million in costs

To address the lag issue, We Energies says it will enter a service agreement with ATC to directly assign costs to data centers during the construction and ramp-up period.

We Energies says this will save ratepayers in ATC’s footprint around $561 million through 2028.

If approved, We Energies customers will avoid $130 million in extra costs in 2027 and 2028, according to the utility’s electric rate proposal filed April 1.

A spokesperson for ATC said the company continues to work with utilities on ways to assign costs to “large load customers,” including data centers.

“Under the concepts being considered, a large load customer would pay the financing costs of transmission facilities while under construction,” the ATC spokesperson said. “Also, customers would be charged for the full amount of transmission service for new, large loads they request, at the time they request it to be available, for a minimum period of 10 years regardless of when and if the full load shows up.”

The plan would be submitted to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which oversees transmission rates. As part of that process, the state Public Service Commission will likely weigh in on whether the proposal adequately addresses the lag issue.

Francesca Pica can be reached at fpica@usatodayco.com.

From: https://www.jsonline.com/story/money/business/energy/2026/04/10/we-energies-floats-plan-to-cover-data-center-transmission-costs/89212761007/